Listening before measuring

Qualitative fieldwork in Ndola, Zambia

Published on 16 March 2026

In March 2026, Mathilde Lesueur and Pablo Alvarez Aragon travelled to the Copperbelt Province of Zambia to lead qualitative fieldwork for the HARSH project. Over two weeks in the Ndola District, the team conducted focus group discussions and key informant interviews across three peri-urban compounds engaging the mothers, fathers, and primary school teachers whose beliefs and practices the project seeks to understand.
HARSH collaborates within the broader impact evaluation of Healthy Learners, a comprehensive school-based health programme implemented by an NGO of the same name in partnership with the Government of Zambia. Whereas the impact evaluation measures effects on health, attendance, and learning, HARSH asks a complementary question: how do adults in these communities define what counts as children's misbehaviour, which disciplinary responses do they regard as legitimate, and where do they draw the line between correction and harm?
To answer it, HARSH developed an experimental vignette survey: short hypothetical scenarios — a child misbehaving, an adult responding — that respondents are asked to evaluate. Such an instrument only works if its scenarios and terms are ones respondents actually recognise. Imported labels such as "corporal punishment" or "disciplinary severity" risk measuring something different from what parents and teachers mean when they talk about discipline themselves. The qualitative phase was designed to capture that local vocabulary before the survey instrument is finalised.
The fieldwork was preceded by a two-day training programme for enumerators, jointly delivered by Mathilde and Pablo. The trained enumerators subsequently led data collection activities under the supervision of the research team. The team ran 9 focus group discussions — with mothers, fathers, and teachers — and 3 key informant interviews with individual teachers. Discussions covered children's behaviour, discipline practices, gender differences, and adults' aspirations for children.
Rigorous quantitative evidence on sensitive topics such as discipline and violence against children depends on measurement instruments that speak the language of their respondents. The Ndola fieldwork has equipped HARSH with precisely this: a locally resonant vocabulary, a plausible severity gradient, and a set of ecologically valid vignette elements drawn directly from participants' own accounts.

Album

HARSH Research in Zambia
HARSH Research in Zambia
HARSH Research in Zambia
HARSH Research in Zambia
HARSH Research in Zambia